Many small and independent website owners have seen a dramatic drop in traffic—often over 70%—since Google began rolling out AI Overviews, which summarize content at the top of search results. Creators in DIY, travel, lifestyle, and cooking niches say this shift has devastated their businesses, cutting ad revenue and forcing some to shut down or radically rethink their strategies.
Despite Google claiming that AI Overviews are helping users and still driving traffic to quality content, many publishers argue the opposite: users are getting answers without clicking through, which means fewer views and lower earnings. Even sites that follow Google’s own EEAT (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) guidelines have been hit.
In closed-door meetings with creators, Google admitted it couldn’t guarantee recovery, citing that search is fundamentally changing in the AI era. Meanwhile, forums like Reddit and large brands like Wikipedia and TripAdvisor now dominate results, leaving small publishers behind.
The imbalance in power has led to frustration and a feeling of betrayal among content creators who helped build the web’s knowledge base. While some go to platforms like YouTube, others are left questioning the future of independent content in a search landscape increasingly controlled by AI.
Table of Contents
What does this mean for business owners that rely on online sales and traffic?
For business owners who rely on online traffic and sales — especially from organic search — this shift has serious implications:
1. Less Visibility in Google Search
- AI Overviews are answering user queries directly, reducing the need for users to click on actual websites.
- Even high-quality, original content may no longer appear prominently in search results.
- Fewer clicks = fewer leads, sales, and ad revenue.
2. Decline in Ad Revenue and Conversions
- For content-driven businesses (blogs, affiliate sites, publishers), fewer visits = less income.
- For e-commerce, drops in organic traffic may lead to reduced product discovery and sales.
3. Need to Diversify Traffic Sources
- Relying solely on SEO is now riskier than ever.
- Businesses should start investing more in:
- Email marketing (own your list)
- Social media (especially video: YouTube, Instagram, TikTok)
- Direct traffic through brand loyalty
- Paid ads (Google Ads, Meta, Pinterest, etc.)
- Partnerships/influencer marketing
4. Loss of Control Over Content Use
- AI Overviews may use your content without driving traffic back to your site.
- You create the value — but Google serves it up in its own interface, possibly crediting bigger brands or not crediting you at all.
5. Urgent Need to Rethink SEO Strategy
- Focus on brand-building, not just keyword ranking.
- Prioritize unique expertise and personality that AI can’t replicate.
- Consider new formats: video, podcasts, communities, and first-hand experience content.
Bottom Line:
Google’s shift to AI-generated answers means the old “create great content and rank on Google” model is no longer reliable on its own. Business owners must take back control by building stronger direct connections with their audience and spreading their marketing efforts across multiple platforms.
How can I get featured in Google’s AI Overviews?
Getting featured in Google’s AI Overviews (also called AI-generated summaries or AI snapshots) is tricky — but not impossible. While Google hasn’t published a clear formula, we can reverse-engineer some of the signals that seem to influence inclusion.
Here’s how you can increase the chances to appear in AI Overviews:
1. Align with Google’s EEAT Guidelines
Google’s AI systems pull from content that appears credible, trustworthy, and experience-based.
Experience: Use first-person insights (“We tested this”, “In our experience”).
Expertise: Clearly showcase credentials, authorship, and niche knowledge.
Authoritativeness: Get mentioned or linked by other trusted sites in the niche.
Trustworthiness: HTTPS, clear privacy policy, good design, and no spammy elements.
2. Answer Specific Questions Clearly
AI Overviews often extract content that answers search-intent-driven queries directly.
- Use headings like “How to…”, “What is…”, or “Best ways to…”
- Write concise, scannable paragraphs (think: 2-4 lines)
- Use bullet points, tables, or numbered lists when relevant
- Create FAQ sections that mirror common search queries
3. Use Structured Data (Schema Markup)
Help Google understand your content by using the right schema:
- HowTo schema for tutorials and guides
- FAQ schema for Q&A formats
- Review schema for products and services
- Author and Article schema for blog posts with clear authorship
4. Build High-Quality Backlinks and Mentions
Sites featured in Overviews are often ones Google already sees as authoritative.
- Get backlinks from reputable niche blogs, news sites, or industry directories
- Encourage mentions on forums like Reddit, Quora, or even LinkedIn posts
- Collaborate with influencers or journalists in your client’s field
5. Optimize for Featured Snippets and “People Also Ask”
Content that ranks in featured snippets or PAA boxes often overlaps with AI Overview sources.
- Use Google Search Console to identify keywords where you rank in the top 10
- Create targeted content to answer those questions more effectively
6. Monitor What’s Being Pulled Into Overviews
Study existing Overviews in your niche:
- What type of content is showing up?
- Which domains are consistently featured?
- Is the overview quoting a list, a definition, or a step-by-step guide?
You can adapt your content style to match the patterns Google seems to favor.
Important: There’s No Guarantee
Google has said that not every site will be included, even if it follows the best practices. But focusing on clear, experience-based, trustworthy content and structured formatting dramatically improves the odds.
AI Overview Optimization Checklist
1. Identify Target Queries
- Use Google Search Console, Ahrefs, or SEMrush to find questions your client ranks for or is close to ranking.
- Look at “People Also Ask” and forums to find phrasing people actually use.
- Focus on informational and how-to queries (e.g., “how to fix a leaking tap” or “best plants for low light”).
2. Content Formatting
- Use clear H1 and H2 headers with natural language questions.
- Add a concise summary paragraph immediately under the heading.
- Use bullet points, numbered steps, or short paragraphs.
- Include an FAQ section targeting related queries at the end of the post.
3. Schema Markup
- Implement HowTo, FAQ, or Article schema where relevant.
- Use Author schema to show real expertise and connect it with a profile.
- Validate schema with Google’s Rich Results Test.
4. EEAT Signals
- Include the author’s name, photo, and bio with qualifications.
- Link to other relevant content on your site to show depth.
- Make sure the site has a clear About page, Contact page, and Privacy Policy.
- Highlight any awards, certifications, or media features.
5. Authority Building
- Get backlinks from reputable sources in your client’s niche.
- Encourage brand mentions on Reddit, Quora, or forums.
- Build your client’s Google Business Profile if local relevance matters.a
6. Technical and UX
- Ensure mobile-friendly design and fast load times.
- Use HTTPS, and eliminate intrusive popups or aggressive ads.
- Fix broken links and update outdated content regularly.
7. Monitor Performance
- Track impressions vs. clicks in Google Search Console (watch for drop in CTR).
- Use tools like Surfer SEO, Frase, or Clearscope to match top competitors’ format and keyword usage.
- Check if your content is being quoted in AI Overviews (search your target queries manually in an incognito window).
Download your Checklist now!
Final thoughts
Google’s AI Overviews have drastically changed how content is discovered online — and for many independent creators and businesses, the impact has been brutal. Traffic is down, revenue is shrinking, and the old playbook no longer works on its own. But this isn’t the end — it’s a changing point.
For business owners and marketers, the path forward is about adapting. Build real connections with your audience. Focus on content that shows experience and authority. Diversify your traffic sources. And optimize your content not just for keywords, but for clarity, credibility, and structure — the qualities AI is looking for.
Getting featured in AI Overviews won’t come with guarantees, but with the right strategy and tools, you can still earn visibility — and reclaim your edge in the search results.
